Sam Prendergast could be potentially ruled out on Saturday against South Africa following his citing for an alleged hip drop tackle on Pecali Yato that saw Yato go off with a knee injury. He was not sanctioned or carded during the game and will face a wait to see what may now happen with one eye on Saturday’s game.
A number of other players have been ruled out through concussion while Dan Sheehan looks likely to return but James Mc Nabney and Jamie Osbourne will not be involved. Squad depth will be severely tested over the last 2 weeks of the November window.
Andy Farrell has said they are treating this few weeks like a mini World Cup, well now it is time to see have the lessons of 2023 been learned from and solutions found to deal with injuries and potential suspensions.
Ciaran Frawley will come in at out half if Prendergast is rule out and that may mean a debut for Jamie Benson from the bench depending on the outcome of the hearing with Sam Prendergast. It will be a baptism of fire for Jamie Benson who was brought in by Ulster last summer if he is involved on Saturday having not seen game time for Ireland over the opening two weeks.
Andy Farrell has been clear and open in saying this is like a mini World Cup, let’s see have they got a game plan for South Africa before decamping to London to play on Finals weekend. The question of squad depth has come into sharp focus and I will be interested to see who will be put in the 13 jersey over the next 2 games with Jamie Osbourne likely not to be involved through injury.
Ireland have had a number of ”A” fixtures in last 3 years and some of the options used in the 13 jersey in those games have not been included in the squad picked for this run of games. Injury and loss of form will be cited as reasons why certain players were not included but reputation and credit in the bank seem to be key factors for Andy Farrell when he included players who had not been in sparkling form in the URC or Europe.
Guys like Cathal Forde and Dan Kelly have played well for their provinces and will have their phones on as they prepare for the “A” game in Virgin Media Park on Friday where the Irish Under 20s will continue preparations for next year’s 6 Nations with a game of their own before that Irish “A” game.
Using the players available I will now select a 23 to face South Africa :
15 Hugo Keenan
14 Robert Balcoune
13 Robbie Henshaw
12 Stuart Mc Closkey
11 Mack Hansen
10 Ciaran Frawley / Sam Predergast
9 Jamison Gibson Park
8 Nick Timoney
7 Josh Van Der Flier
6 Ryan Baird
5 Tadgh Beirne
4 Joe Mc Carthy
3 Tadgh Furlong
2 Dan Sheehan
1 Andrew Porter
–
16 Ronan Kelleher
17 Tom O Toole
18 Thomas Clarkson
19 Darragh Murray
20 Cian Predergast
21 Craig Casey
22 Jamie Benson/ Ciaran Frawley
23 Tommy O Brien
Here is the 23 I would pick for Saturday. The game on Saturday will be a very physical encounter as has been the case over the past 9 years Rassie Erasmus with South Africa. Ireland have not hit the high notes this November and will need to put in 2 strong back to back showings.
We have heard that there is plenty to come from this side and Saturday is the chance to show themselves and others that there still is fight left in the old dog….
